Byline: Guy Martin / Johannesburg
Over a dozen Asian nations have cruise missiles in their inventories
and several of them - notably China, India, Taiwan and Pakistan - have
indigenous production capabilities. Although many nations possess
anti-ship cruise missiles similar to the US Harpoon, a growing number
are fielding advanced land attack systems.
Cruise missiles give countries political and military influence
disproportionate to their size. Indeed, cruise missiles are no longer
the domain of the great powers and the proliferation of them is
something many analysts consider to be more of a concern than the
proliferation of ballistic missiles, due to their affordability,
relative ease of use, availability and accuracy. Cruise missiles require
less maintenance and operator training than aircraft and are
comparatively cheap and reliable. Because of their relatively small
size, they can be launched from a wide variety of platforms – even
shipping containers. It is therefore not surprising that the number of
cruise missiles in the Asia-Pacific region is on the rise. Proliferation
is being hastened by the regional tensions between India and Pakistan,
China and Taiwan and North and South Korea.
India
India has long been a client for Soviet weapon systems and has
several Russian-made cruise missiles in its inventory, such as the Kh-35
Uran/3M-24 (SS-N-25 Switchblade), Kh-31 (AS-17 Krypton) and 3M-54 Club
(SS-N-27 Sizzler). India has also partnered with Russia to jointly
develop and produce the export version of the SS-N-26 (3M55
Oniks/Yakhont), resulting in the PJ-10 or Brahmos. In 1998 Russia’s NPO
Mashinostroyeniya and India’s Defence Research and Development
Organisation (DRDO) created the Brahmos Aerospace joint venture to
develop the weapon.
Brahmos is launched with a rocket engine and is then powered by a
ramjet, giving it a top speed of Mach 2.8. The 3.9 ton, 8.4 metre long
missile can fly as low as 10 metres above the surface and is armed with a
200 kg warhead for the ship/land-based variant and a 300 kg warhead for
the air-launched version. Brahmos has a range of 290 km, which was
imposed to comply with Missile Technology Control Regime restrictions,
to which Russia is a signatory.
Brahmos was first test fired in June 2001. India is busy trialling
improved versions of the missile with better guidance systems and
software, and recently fired a steep dive Block III version (for use in
mountainous terrain) from a transporter erector launcher at the end of
March. The air- and submarine-launched versions of the missile are in
development, with an underwater launch scheduled for later this year.
The Indian Navy inducted the system in 2005 aboard the INS Rajput,
while the Army introduced the Block I missile in June 2007. Brahmos is
now fully operational with two regiments of the Indian Army, while
another regiment will soon accept the weapon for deployment along the
border with China in Arunachal Pradesh. India has plans to install
Brahmos on a number of platforms, including Rajput destroyers, Kolkata
destroyers, Shivalik frigates, Talwar frigates, Kilo submarines, Il-38SD
and Tu-142M maritime patrol aircraft and Su-30MKI fighters. India is
expected to receive around a thousand Brahmos missiles over the next
decade while another thousand will be exported.
Russia and India are working on a follow-on to the Brahmos. The
Brahmos 2 will be able to fly faster than Mach 5, making it the fastest
cruise missile in the world. It will be very similar in size and shape
to the first generation and is intended to be compatible with those
launchers. It is estimated that it will only be around five years before
the missile is produced, when it will arm India’s future destroyers and
frigates.
For more than five years the DRDO has been developing the Nirbhay
long range cruise missile, which will be available in ground-,
submarine- and air-launched versions and carry a payload of around 450
kg. Launch is via a rocket, with a turbojet providing subsonic delivery
to the target. Range of the INS/GPS-guided weapon is estimated to be
around 800-1 000 km. Nirbhay will complement the shorter range Brahmos.
Testing is expected to commence early this year.
Pakistan
Across the border, Pakistan has, with Chinese help, obtained a
stockpile of nuclear-capable Hatf-7/Babur land-attack cruise missiles,
which were developed in response to events in India, and assisted by the
recovery of two nearly intact Tomahawks in southern Pakistan in 1998.
Work began in the 1990s and serial production commenced in October 2005.
Launched by a solid fuel rocket booster, the Babur is powered by a
turbojet engine giving a speed of Mach .8. Guidance is via a combination
of INS/terrain contour matching and GPS. The weapon can be launched
from land, sea or submarines. Strike range is 500-700 km.
Pakistan’s National Engineering and Scientific Commission (NESCOM)
has also developed the Ra’ad/Hatf 8 air-launched cruise missile. It is
not an air-launched version of Babur but a new design capable of
carrying nuclear or conventional warheads. The first announced test
launch took place in August 2007 aboard a Mirage IIIEA, with several
test firings taking place over the next three years. Range is estimated
to be around 350 km, against land and ship targets. Guidance is believed
to be via GPS and infrared using terrain matching techniques.
China
China is a big cruise missile user - its preoccupation with such
weapons reflecting its earlier lack of aircraft capable of penetrating
enemy air defences. It has prioritised land-based cruise and ballistic
missile programmes and is expanding its stocks, developing dozens of
models for both domestic use and export.
In 1985 China tested the X-600 turbojet powered cruise missile, which
evolved into the turbofan-powered Hong Niao-1 (HN-1), development of
which began in 1988. This later evolved into the longer-range (1 500 km)
HN-2, which was believed to have been tested in 1995 or 1997. The Hong
Niao-3 (HN-3) is thought to be a stealthier, more accurate HN-2 model
with a range of 2 500 km. It was successfully tested in August 2004 and
later entered service with the People’s Liberation Army. China is
working on the Hong Niao-2000 (HN-2000) next generation cruise missile,
apparently equipped with advanced navigation technologies for pinpoint
accuracy (1-3 metres). The missile will feature stealth technologies, a
supersonic terminal flight phase and a range of several thousand
kilometres.
The DongHai 10 (DH-10)/ChangJian-10 (CJ-10) land attack cruise
missile made its public debut in October 2009. Developed by the China
Aerospace Science and Industry Corporation (CASIC), it is a conventional
or nuclear land attack cruise missile with integrated inertial
navigation system, GPS and terrain contour and scene mapping guidance.
Range may be around 4 000 km. It is believed that several hundred have
been deployed, but very little is known about this important weapon
system.
China has a long history of local cruise missile development,
particularly with regard to anti-ship weapons. In 1959 the Soviet Union
supplied China with P-15/SS-N-2 Styx missiles, which were manufactured
under license as the SY-1/CSS-N-1 Scrubbrush. In the 1960s China
developed the missile into the Hai Ying-1 (HY-1/CSSC-2 Silkworm/CSS-N-2
Safflower) and later the improved HY-2/C-201/CSSC-3 Seersucker. From
this family emerged the turbojet-powered HY-4/CSSC-7 Sadsack and
air-launched YJ-6/C-601/CAS-1 Kraken. The YJ-61/C-611 is an upgraded,
extended range version, which entered service in 1990. China also
produced the HY-3/C-301/CSSC-6 Sawhorse and YJ-16/C-101/CSSC-5 Saples
missiles. The latter had, by 2005 been replaced by the C-801 and C-802.
China developed the YJ-6 into the KD-63 (Kong Di-63)/YJ-63
air-launched cruise missile, which emerged into open view in 2005. It
was most likely the first indigenous long-range airborne standoff weapon
to be fielded by the People’s Liberation Army Air Force and
incorporated systems such as electro-optical seeker and datalink.
The C-801/C-802 series of missiles, developed in the 1980s, are some
of the most important in China’s anti-ship cruise missile arsenal. The
YJ-1/YJ-8/C-801 was approved for service in 1987 as a surface-launched
anti-ship missile (CSS-N-4 Sardine). The subsonic missile has a range of
45 km while the YJ-81 version has a range of 80 km.
The anti-ship YJ-2/YJ-82 (C-802)/CSSC-8/CSS-N-8 Saccade was first
seen in 1989 and is based on the YJ-1/C-801 but replaced the solid
propellant rocket with a turbojet. Believed to have entered service in
1994, the YJ-2 has a 165 kg warhead and a range of 130 km. Improved
versions are the YJ-21 (180 km range) and YJ-22 (400 km range). The
recently unveiled C-802AKG air-launched weapon has a range of 220-250
km.
The YJ-83 (C-803) is a more modern supersonic version of the YJ-82,
apparently having a range of 150-250 km. It can be launched from the
air, ships and submarine torpedo tubes. JH-7 aircraft equipped with the
YJ-83 provides China with a power-projection capability of more than 1
900 km – more than enough to cross the Taiwan Strait.
The KongDi-88 (KD-88) air-launched land attack cruise missile was
developed from the C-802 family and unveiled in 2006 under the export
designation C-802KD. Powered by a turbojet engine, the missile can
deliver a 164 kg warhead at Mach .9 over a distance of around 180-200
km.
Some of China’s other cruise missiles include the C-701, C-704, C-705
and turbojet-powered YJ-62 (C-602). This has a reported range of 280
km, a cruise altitude of 30 m and a 300 kg warhead. It debuted in public
in 2006 and, although an anti-ship missile, has a land attack
capability as well.
In addition to developing its own weapons, China has a number of
Russian cruise missiles in service, including the 600 km range Kh-65SE
and Kh-41 Moskit (SS-N-22 Sunburn) supersonic sea-skimming anti-ship
cruise missile, which has a range of 250 km. The Moskits were procured
together with the two Sovremenny destroyers purchased from Russia. In
addition, the 3M-54 Club (SS-N-27 Sizzler) is placed on China’s
Kilo-class submarines. Ukraine apparently exported 3 000 km range
nuclear capable Kh-55 (AS-15 Kent) missiles to China.
Taiwan
Taiwan faces what is probably the most severe land attack cruise
missile threat of any country, with hundreds of Chinese cruise weapons
pointed at it. For its part, Taiwan possesses the Wan Chien air-launched
conventional land attack cruise missile, which was developed in
response to the 1996 Taiwan Strait crisis. The 240 km range
turbojet-powered missile can be used against both ground and ship
targets and launched from the air. Mass production will start in around
2014.
Wan Chien is one of a number of indigenous weapons systems, including
the Tien Chien IIA anti-radiation missile and Hsiung Feng series of
anti-ship missiles. Starting with the Hsiung Feng I, Taiwan developed
the 80-160 km range turbojet-powered Hsiung Feng 2, which entered
service in the early 1990s. The Hsiung Feng 3 is a ramjet-powered
supersonic cruise missile aimed at ship and land-based targets. The
ramjet powered weapon gives a speed of around Mach 2.5 while cruising at
between 20 and 200 metres altitude. The +/- 150 km range missile has
been in development since 1995 and is believed to have entered service
in 2008.
Development of the Hsiung Feng 2E (HF-2E) ground-launched
conventional land attack missile was first reported in 2001 and
production confirmed in late 2010, with several hundred being planned to
be built. The missile has a range of 600+ km and is reportedly powered
by a turbofan, and carries a 500 kg warhead. Guidance is thought to be
through INS, GPS and terrain matching with imaging infrared terminal
guidance.
Japan
Japan has developed several indigenous cruise missiles, starting in
the 1970s with the air-launched ASM-1 (Type 80) anti-ship weapon. It
entered service with the Japan Air Self Defence Force in 1982 and is
powered by a solid rocket/turbojet, giving a range of 50 km. The ASM-1
was developed into the ASM-1C (Type 91), which is lighter and has an
extended 65 km range. It entered service in 1994. The ground-launched
version is designated SSM-1 (Type 88) while the ship-launched variant is
called the SSM-1B (Type 90). The ASM-1 series has been supplemented by
the newer ASM-2 (Type 93), in production from 1993, which features a
turbojet engine and new imaging infrared seeker. This air-launched
cruise missile has a 150 kg or 225 kg warhead and a maximum range of 100
km. The Type 96 variant features various upgrades and entered service
in 1997.
Mitsubishi Heavy Industries is developing the stealthy ASM-3/SSM-2 as
a successor to the ASM-2 and SSM-1 for use against ship and land
targets. The new missile has a solid rocket propellant/ramjet motor and a
range of more than 200 km. It reportedly has dual-mode imaging infrared
and active radar seekers.
Korea
Due to American restrictions limiting the production of its own
ballistic missiles, South Korea has placed a heavy emphasis on
developing long-range cruise missiles to defend against its northern
neighbour. In the late 1990s South Korea began developing the
ASM/SSM-700K Hae Seong ground, ship, air and submarine-launched
anti-ship missile. The turbojet-powered weapon was ordered into
production in 2006, with an initial order for 100 for deployment aboard
KDX-II and KDX-III destroyers. The Hae Seong has a range of around 150
km.
In October 2006 South Korea first test fired a new land attack cruise
missile designated Hyunmoo 3 (ground launch) and Cheon Ryong (for
maritime deployment). Designed by the Agency for Defence Development, it
had an initial range of 500 km, but the Hyunmoo 3B has a range of 1 000
km and the Hyunmoo 3C a range of 1 500 km, enabling it to target all of
North Korea’s territory. The subsonic, turbofan-powered missile has a
payload of 500 kg, with terrain matching/inertial/GPS guidance.
Production began in 2009, with deployment along the borders and on KDX-3
destroyers.
In December last year Korean media reported that the government had
set aside 388 billion won (US$343 million) to buy 177 stealthy standoff
cruise missiles and will this year select between the Joint
Air-to-Surface Standoff Missile (JASSM) and Germany’s Taurus, for use
aboard its F-15Ks and F-16Ks. Seoul could deploy the first weapons in
late 2013.
North Korea has a varied cruise missile capability but its anti-ship
cruise missile arsenal is not a great threat to South Korea’s navy as it
mainly comprises of several Styx variants, including the land-based
SSC-2B Samlet and HY-1/CSSC-2 Silkworm or HY-2/CSSC-3 Seersucker.
Pyongyang has the ability to produce the HY-2 as well as the locally
developed, extended range AG-1.
Australia
Under Air 5418 Phase 1 Australia is purchasing Lockheed Martin’s
AGM-158 Joint Air-to-Surface Standoff Missile and in March 2006 selected
the JASSM to equip the Royal Australian Air Force’s F/A-18 Hornets,
after eliminating the Boeing AGM-84H/K Stand-Off Land Attack Missile –
Expanded Response (SLAM-ER) and Taurus KEPD 350.
The JASSM is a stealthy standoff cruise missile being developed for
the US Air Force. Although development began in 1995, service entry was
delayed until 2009 due to several failures during testing, notably
because of problems with the GPS guidance system. The AGM-158A is
powered by a Teledyne CAE J402 turbojet, giving a subsonic cruising
speed and a range of 370 km (230 miles). Guidance is via inertial
navigation with GPS updates, with target recognition and terminal homing
via an imaging infrared seeker. Thanks to a datalink, it can strike
relocatable targets. The warhead is a WDU-42/B 450 kg penetrator.
Netherlands and Finland have also selected the JASSM.
A number of other nations in the Asia-Pacific have invested in cruise
missile capabilities, but are limited to anti-ship weapons. Bangladesh,
Brunei, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam all have anti-ship
cruise missiles, including the C-801, C-802, AGM-84 Harpoon, HY-2,
Exocet, Gabriel, Kh-31, Kh-35, Kh-41 and Kh-59.